Jump to navigation

President Macron pledges to end to second-hand clothes trade

An EU bloc-wide exporting ban will have mixed effects on African economies

The French government's plans to push other EU countries to impose a bloc-wide ban on the export of used clothes could be another counter-productive piece of EU law.

Africa imports US$1 billion a year of second-hand clothes, accounting for 30% of the global market. But the industry is a divisive topic among policy-makers. 

The East African Community agreed to ban second-hand clothing imports in 2016, on the grounds that they were stalling the growth of the local textiles industry. However, this prompted a lengthy trade dispute with the United States, which threatened suspension from the African Growth and Opportunity Act, which offers tariff and quota-free access to the US market for African exports. In the event, only Rwanda imposed the ban and was suspended from AGOA as a result (AC Vol 59 No 7, AGOA hits Mitumba).

But while economists contend that second-hand clothing is a barrier to African industrialisation and supply chain development in textiles, thousands of market sellers across the continent make a livelihood from the market.

That tension was exploited by Kenyan President William Ruto during the 2022 presidential election after his opponent, Raila Odinga, proposed a ban on 'mitumba'. Ruto focused his presidential campaign around supporting Kenya's 'hustler nation' of small businesses and traders (AC Vol 63 No 13, Raila's old clothes).

The French environment ministry, which says that Paris has the support of Denmark and Sweden, contends that the ban will reduce textile waste and the environmental damage it causes. Europe currently dumps 90% of its used clothes in Africa and Asia.

With the EU institutions set to shut down for several months from April, ahead of the European Parliament elections in June, and a new European Commission set to take office in September, the French proposal could be put on hold until later in the year.



Related Articles

AGOA hits Mitumba

Rwanda has found itself an unlikely victim of President Donald Trump's international trade war. In a 29 March letter to Congress, the US President announced plans to partly...


Raila's old clothes

Of all the promises made on the campaign trail, Kenyan presidential contender Raila Odinga's plans to curb the import of second-hand clothes, known as mitumba, has caused the...


As external support ebbs, states seek to plug the revenue gap

Efforts to raise domestic funds are colliding with political constraints – and public trust remains elusive as global reforms falter

As indebted African governments confront declining aid flows and western reluctance to reform the international financial system, they are again eyeing ways to boost domestic revenues and tap...


Africa in 2019: The youngest continent fights back

Shakier economies and an accelerating youth revolt dominate our second special issue on the year ahead

There are clear parallels between the wave of protests demanding radical change across Africa this month with the early days of the North African revolt in 2011, known...

READ FOR FREE

Non-Government Who's Who

Stephen Lewis: United Nations' Special Envoy, HIV-AIDS in Africa, 2001-06; Deputy Director, UN Children's Fund, 1995-1999; Canada's Permanent Representative, UN, 1984-98; was Coordinator, Graça Machel study on children...