Jump to navigation

A disputed levy

Report finds EU's new carbon import levy will hit many third countries less than feared but another think-tank says Africa faces possible 4% drop in exports to Europe

The economic effects of the EU's new carbon import levy are set to be far smaller than feared by many third countries, many of them African, according to a report published on Monday by Sandbag, a think-tank focused on EU climate policies.

The report contends that foreign manufacturers can minimise the charges they face under the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism by utilising 'resource shuffling' – 'selectively exporting to Europe the low-emission intensity goods to enjoy lower CBAM charges, while the high-emission goods are kept for other markets'.

'Although the EU wishes to avoid such practice, it might not manage to do so under current rules,' the report adds. However, Sandbag's research does not look at the costs that could be faced by African states.

The levy will apply to imports of a group of products including steel, cement, iron and aluminium and the African Climate Foundation has estimated that the levy could result in a 4% drop in Africa's exports to Europe, with South Africa and Mozambique among those likely to be worst affected (AC Vol 64 No 13, How Brussels's green tax will hit Africa).

However, trade experts tell Africa Confidential that these effects could be mitigated if the EU provides financial and technical support to allow Mozambique, whose energy for aluminium production comes from the South African grid, to be plugged into a domestic energy source.

Though South Africa is still threatening to challenge the CBAM at the World Trade Organization, EU Trade Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis said last week that Brussels was in talks with a group of countries to assuage their concerns about the levy – under which payments will only start in 2026 (AC Dispatches, 28/2/24, Carbon row heads to the World Trade Organization).

Other African ministers have complained about the lack of consultation by the EU Commission on the levy, pointing out that their carbon emissions are very low.



Related Articles

How Brussels's green tax will hit Africa

Europe's carbon levy has become law with African states in line to suffer collateral damage

After two years of debate, the European Parliament has passed a carbon pricing mechanism which will apply to all countries trading with member states of the European Union...


DISPATCHES

Carbon row heads to the World Trade Organization

South Africa and India have accused the EU of using environmental issues as a cover for protectionism in its new CBAM

African countries are set to raise formal complaints about the effects of some of the European Union's new laws on environmental protection and carbon at this week's Ministerial...

READ FOR FREE

The next stage in the battle over global tax rules

Plans for a UN authority on tax policy backed by African states are gaining ground in spite of western resistance

How are western states going to respond after losing a battle at the UN General Assembly last November over how global tax rules are negotiated? The European Union...


Getting the right numbers

It is the biggest economic success story in Africa. The growth of mobile telephony is phenomenal – in numbers, in jobs created and in the economic development it is driving. African software engineers are pioneering the development of payment systems over mobile telephones, first in Kenya, then Rwanda and South Africa, and now Nigeria. Until the late 1990s, few mobile phone operators regarded Africa as a viable mass market. They lacked accurate information about the continent’s spending power and a vision of how services could be developed. Initially, most companies – except for South Africa’s MTN – steered clear of Nigeria (AC Vol 43 No 20, Scrambling for Africa). Now it is one of the world’s biggest telecommunications markets

Between 1998 and 2008, the number of mobile phone subscribers in Africa increased from 4 million to 260 million while network coverage increased from 10% to over 60%...


As Trump turns off the tap, Guterres wields the knife

The UN Secretary-General hopes radical restructuring and austerity can rescue the organisation as multilateralism starts to split at the seams

Instead of celebrating its 80th birthday, there is a serious chance that the UN headquarters will have to declare a form of institutional bankruptcy at its General Assembly...

READ FOR FREE