Jump to navigation

UN agency warns against African Eurobonds

Economists are worried that high yields on new borrowing by developing countries are unsustainable

Several African states may have returned to the Eurobond market in recent months, but a new report by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) has warned that the gap in borrowing costs between developing countries and wealthy states continues to widen.

'The debt and development crises faced by many developing countries continues to worsen,' said UNCTAD in its April Trade and Development report.

'The increase in public resources and export revenues that must be channelled towards public and publicly guaranteed debt service is a key dimension of the current crisis.'

Benin, Côte d'Ivoire and Kenya have tapped the Eurobond market this year. Though Kenya's $1.5 billion in new debt which matures in 2031 was the most expensive, President William Ruto's government has seen obvious benefits from going to market: its currency has strengthened by more than 15% against the dollar since issuing the bond in February (AC Vol 65 No 4, Ruto gambles on Eurobonds). Kenya is also set to receive additional funding from the World Bank and International Monetary Fund in the coming months.

Kenya's interest rate of 10.375% is significantly higher than the yields on Côte d'Ivoire's two Eurobonds issued last month, worth $2.6bn, at 7.875% and 8.5%, which mature in 2033 and 2037 respectively. Benin's debt comes at an 8.375% interest rate and matures in 2038. In all cases, the yields are above the 7% baseline figure that economists cite as the highest at which borrowing is sustainable.

Even so, the successful returns to market had been cited as evidence that widespread African debt distress, and the default of Ghana, Zambia and Ethiopia, which followed the Covid-19 pandemic was a thing of the past.

In Kenya's case, economists have warned that the boost to economic confidence will be short-lived unless growth and tax revenue collection significantly exceed expectations to ease debt-servicing pressures.

Pointing to the recent Eurobond issues, UNCTAD noted that 'Implicit borrowing costs, gauged by yields, are substantially above existing borrowing costs, as measured by the average weight of existing bond coupons.'

'Countries capable of issuing bonds do so at higher coupon rates, compared with bonds being currently repaid. This has detrimental effects on debt dynamics, especially in a context of low economic growth, and more broadly on the allocation of public spending.'



Related Articles

Ruto gambles on Eurobonds

Nairobi's Treasury joins borrowers paying over 10% interest to meet escalating debt service demands

At the heart of the government's plan to issue US$1.5 billion of debt at 10.375% for a buy-back deal is President William Ruto's determination to avoid protracted debt...


Getting the right numbers

It is the biggest economic success story in Africa. The growth of mobile telephony is phenomenal – in numbers, in jobs created and in the economic development it is driving. African software engineers are pioneering the development of payment systems over mobile telephones, first in Kenya, then Rwanda and South Africa, and now Nigeria. Until the late 1990s, few mobile phone operators regarded Africa as a viable mass market. They lacked accurate information about the continent’s spending power and a vision of how services could be developed. Initially, most companies – except for South Africa’s MTN – steered clear of Nigeria (AC Vol 43 No 20, Scrambling for Africa). Now it is one of the world’s biggest telecommunications markets

Between 1998 and 2008, the number of mobile phone subscribers in Africa increased from 4 million to 260 million while network coverage increased from 10% to over 60%...


The bonus culture

Payments by oil and mineral companies to ensure that governments sign on the dotted line are not always what they seem

New or renewed deals to explore for or produce minerals must be licensed by governments. When deals are signed, companies expect to hand over a bonus or other...


Twilight Zone

Europe's new money has no room for favours to Francophone Africa

The Paris-backed CFA Franc Zone is under pressure in Africa again as eleven European Union nations brace themselves for their new common currency, the euro (AC Vol 39...


Fishing for votes

Environmental campaigners such as Greenpeace have long protested about the links between voting at the International Whaling Commission and Japanese aid. That was before evidence that Japanese activities, including the paying...