Jump to navigation

Missing the trees for the wood

Smallholder farmers could lose millions as Brussels enforces new rules to stop destruction of forests

The EU's deforestation law is facing growing pushback from African states and the wider international community over fears that the compliance burdens imposed by the new law will be prohibitively high for smallholder farmers.

The law, which was adopted in April 2023 and comes into force this year, was hailed by EU lawmakers as a landmark in the bloc's push towards sustainable business practices and slashing carbon emissions. It will require exporters of products made from commodities such as coffee, cocoa, timber and rubber to prove that they were not associated with deforestation at any point in their supply chain (Dispatches 16/5/22, Euro MPs back action on cocoa prices).

African states are at different levels of preparedness for the new rules. Officials in Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana, the world's main cocoa producers, say that they will be ready; but Ethiopian officials have indicated that they will ask the EU executive for more time to comply.

Kenyan officials say that most of their smallholder farmers are unaware of the new European law.

At February's Munich Security conference, Mia Mottley, the Prime Minister of Barbados, warned that the EU's new anti-deforestation law would prevent 'millions of people in Africa' from selling their products to the EU market.

'You can't work good for the planet and do bad for the people. If people can't live, and people can't have peace and the people can't have prosperity,' said Mottley.

Similar complaints were brought at the World Trade Organization's ministerial conference in Abu Dhabi in late February (Dispatches 28/2/24, Carbon row heads to the World Trade Organization).

Uganda, which is Africa's second largest coffee exporter after Ethiopia, says that it has secured an arrangement with the EU that will see the Uganda Coffee Development Authority present due diligence certificates for batches of coffee, rather than individual farmers. That could help reduce the compliance burden on smallholder farmers.



Related Articles

DISPATCHES

Euro MPs back action on cocoa prices

As production costs escalate, Ghanaian and Ivorian officials are lobbying the EU to raise prices for cocoa bean exports

As Africa's cocoa producers face growing financial pressures, they have won backing from European Union MPs to open talks on a price pact as part of wider discussions...

READ FOR FREE

DISPATCHES

Carbon row heads to the World Trade Organization

South Africa and India have accused the EU of using environmental issues as a cover for protectionism in its new CBAM

African countries are set to raise formal complaints about the effects of some of the European Union's new laws on environmental protection and carbon at this week's Ministerial...

READ FOR FREE

Trading places

Large numbers of Chinese nationals have been heading to Africa’s major cities to get their own slice of skyrocketing China-Africa trade

Traders are the visible target for the merchants, unions, consumers and politicians angered by the impact of China’s growing ties to Africa. Nevertheless, some African governments are resisting...


Minerals meltdown

China is taking advantage of the global economic crisis to restructure its mining industry. A 4 trillion renminbi (US$586 billion) stimulus plan, announced late last year, encompasses sector-specific reform measures put...


Tripling trade

African countries are calling for more investment in local manufacturing and processing capacity – and India's private sector is ready to oblige

India's diplomats started off the year with a flurry of official visits to North African countries with a view to strengthening economic ties there. External Affairs Minister Salman...